Why should I call a lawyer before my insurance company after a car accident in Georgia?
Asked in Cartersville, GA on May 5, 2019 Last answered on March 5, 20262 answers
Your insurance company has one goal when presented with a claim: to pay as little as possible. After all, this is how the company makes money. When you are in a car accident, you may think you must call your insurance company immediately. They may even be friendly and sympathetic on the telephone. You have several good reasons to call an attorney before giving a statement to any insurance company, however.
The insurance company may try to use the information you give them against you when processing your claim. This applies to both your own insurance company and that of any other driver involved in the accident. Of course, you must exchange insurance information with the other driver, but you do not have to give them a statement.
You May Not Be Prepared To Give A Statement
After a car accident, most people are shaken up. They are not prepared to handle the stressful aspects of an accident investigation, especially if they are dealing with injuries. They may face insurance companies, claims adjusters and accident investigators. You may feel confused and upset right after the accident, and make a statement that you later need to correct. If you change your story, however, the insurance company may use that against you. They could even deny your claim.
You do have to file a claim shortly after an accident, but you have plenty of time to consult with an attorney first. An attorney can help you prepare for this discussion, or even talk to the insurance company on your behalf. In addition, an attorney will start gathering evidence on your behalf in order to build a strong case for you.
You May Not Know The Severity Of Your Injuries Yet
In many cases, people suffer injuries in a car accident that don’t become fully apparent for days, or even weeks after the accident. This can happen with all types of injuries, but especially traumatic brain injuries, and neck and back injuries. For this reason, you should always seek medical help after a car accident, even if your pain seems minor or trivial at the time.
You may tell the insurance company you feel okay because you walked away from the accident, only to find out a few days later that you have developed symptoms that are growing worse. The insurance company will use your initial statement against you when you make an injury claim. Your attorney can advise you about the types of statements you want to avoid when talking to the insurance company.
They May Try To Convince You To Settle
If another driver’s negligence caused your injuries, their insurance company will pressure you to settle right away. They may contact you with a low-ball offer, hoping you will accept it before you consult with an attorney and before you really understand the extent of your injuries. An attorney should review any settlement offer. They can advise you regarding the true value of your claim, which can depend on many factors. An experienced personal injury attorney can often negotiate a better settlement for you because of their knowledge regarding claims and the fact that an attorney can take your case to trial if the insurance company fails to offer an appropriate settlement.
Going through a car accident is bad enough. Being revictimized by the insurance company is unacceptable. A reputable personal injury attorney will stand by your side throughout your case to handle the insurance company and their lawyers and demand for the compensation you deserve.
Virtual Appointments In Georgia, after a car accident—especially if you’ve been injured, there’s significant damage, or fault is disputed—it’s often wise to consult a personal injury attorney before (or immediately after) speaking in detail with any insurance company (yours or the other driver’s). While you’re generally required to notify your own insurer promptly (most policies mandate “as soon as possible” reporting to avoid claim denial or reduction), you don’t have to give a detailed recorded statement, describe fault, or discuss injuries without guidance.
Many Georgia attorneys and legal resources emphasize contacting a lawyer first (or very early) for these key reasons:
1. Insurance Companies Prioritize Minimizing Payouts
Adjusters (even from your own company) are trained to limit liability and payouts. Their goal is to pay as little as possible, and they may use friendly, sympathetic tones to get information that can later be used against you. A lawyer helps you understand what to say (or not say) and can handle communications on your behalf, preventing accidental damage to your claim.
2. Avoid Giving Statements That Can Hurt Your Case
Anything you say—especially in a recorded statement—can be twisted or used to dispute fault, minimize injuries, or argue pre-existing conditions. For example, saying “I feel okay right now” might be cited later to downplay soft-tissue injuries that worsen over days/weeks. An attorney advises you on safe responses (e.g., “Refer all questions to my lawyer”) or speaks directly with the adjuster, shielding you from pitfalls.
3. Preserve Evidence and Strengthen Your Claim Early
The first hours/days after an accident are critical: scene photos fade, witnesses become hard to reach, black box data or dashcam footage can be lost, and medical records need proper documentation. A lawyer can guide immediate steps (e.g., getting medical treatment, gathering evidence) and preserve key details before insurers lock in a narrative.
4. Protect Against Lowball Offers and Unfair Denials
Insurers often push quick settlements that undervalue your claim (medical bills, lost wages, pain/suffering, future care). In Georgia (a fault-based state with modified comparative negligence under O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33), they may try to shift partial blame to you to reduce recovery. An attorney evaluates the full value, negotiates aggressively, and prepares for litigation if needed (statute of limitations is generally 2 years under O.C.G.A. § 9-3-33).
5. Handle Complex Situations Like Uninsured/Underinsured Drivers
If the at-fault driver has low/no coverage, your UM/UIM policy may apply—but insurers scrutinize these claims heavily. A lawyer ensures proper notice, counters bad faith tactics (potential extra penalties), and maximizes recovery from all sources.
6. No Upfront Cost and Free Consultations
Georgia car accident lawyers typically work on contingency (no fee unless you recover, often 33-40%). Most offer free initial consultations, so you can get advice quickly—often the same day—without risk. Many in Atlanta will even meet you at the hospital or come to you.
Practical Advice for Right After the Accident
• Priorities first: Ensure safety, call 911 if injured or damage >$500 (required police report in Georgia), exchange basic info (license, insurance, contact), take photos, get witness details.
• Notify your insurer briefly if needed (to meet policy terms), but limit it to facts like “I was in an accident at [location/time]; other driver was [basic fault if clear]; injuries unknown/being checked.”
• Call a lawyer ASAP—ideally before a detailed insurance call. Search for Atlanta car accident specialists; many are available 24/7.
This protects your rights and often leads to better outcomes. Delaying legal help can make things harder against well-resourced insurers. This is a general overview based on Georgia practices and attorney guidance—not personalized legal advice. If your accident involved injuries, a drunk driver, or other complications, reach out to a local attorney soon for a free review of your specifics. Sorry you’re dealing with this—hope you’re okay.
Don't see what you are looking for? Ask a Super Lawyers Selectee - it's free!
Submit a question and get answers for free from a Super Lawyers Selectee.
Ask a questionThe information contained in this web site is intended to convey general information. It should not be construed as legal advice or opinion. It is not an offer to represent you, nor is it intended to create an attorney-client relationship.