I feel that I was set up and provoked so my spouse could get control of property. DVO. Is this something the court would consider?

Asked in Hickory, NC on December 11, 2025 Last answered on September 1, 2026

Recently purchased a house and dumped all my savings into it. I believe that my wife and stepson planned out an argument to provoke me and take out DVO To get control of my assets/ property. Neither one helped with purchase or repairs. They locked me out and were waiting at the entrance. I was intoxicated. My stepson produced a gun and I slapped him and tried to get it. He then held me and my brother in law at gunpoint. 911 was called. I think my wife was acting the whole time. She took out papers and police arrested me without talking to any witnesses there besides those two.

1 answer

Angela W. McIlveen
Answered by:

Angela W. McIlveen

Gastonia, NC
McIlveen Family Law Firm 704-368-2924
Virtual Appointments
Answer

Yes. The court can consider the circumstances surrounding the incident, including what happened before the physical contact, whether a weapon was involved, the credibility of the witnesses, and whether any actions were taken in self-defense. However, simply believing that your spouse planned or provoked the confrontation does not automatically defeat a Domestic Violence Protective Order.

Based on the facts you describe, the sequence of events will be extremely important. You acknowledge slapping your stepson, but you also state that he produced a firearm and that you were attempting to take it from him. North Carolina's domestic violence statute specifically excludes acts of self-defense, so the court will need to determine what actually occurred and why.

A 50B proceeding can also temporarily affect possession of a residence. A judge may grant one party possession of the home and exclude the other party as part of a protective order. That does not, however, determine permanent ownership of the property. Who paid for the house or repairs may matter in a later property-division case, but it does not by itself determine who may temporarily occupy the residence under a protective order.

You should preserve any available evidence, including 911 recordings, photographs, videos, text messages, witness information, police reports, and evidence concerning the firearm. If criminal charges are also pending, speak with an attorney before making detailed statements about the incident because what you say in the 50B proceeding could affect the criminal case. Most importantly, comply strictly with any existing protective order unless and until the court changes it.

September 1, 2026

Don't see what you are looking for? Ask a Super Lawyers Selectee - it's free!

Submit a question and get answers for free from a Super Lawyers Selectee.

Ask a question
Disclaimer

The information contained in this web site is intended to convey general information. It should not be construed as legal advice or opinion. It is not an offer to represent you, nor is it intended to create an attorney-client relationship.

Page Generated: 0.039198875427246 sec